Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

2-Pole Vs. 4-Pole raybet For Submersible Solids Handling Pumps

Grundfos
Grundfos 2-poles vs 4-pole Solids Handling

2-Pole Vs. 4-Pole raybet For Submersible Solids Handling Pumps

By: Grundfos

The Situation
Historically, in the United States, there has been a broad tendency to specify 4-pole nominal 1750 rpm motors for use on submersible solids handling pumps. 2-pole 3500 nominal rpm motors are not only becoming widely accepted – they are increasingly the preferred solution for lower flow/higher head applications. There are a number of important considerations behind this change.

Grundfos 2-poles vs 4-pole (1)

Figure 1: Automated Hydraulic Design

So exactly what has changed?
New technologies have altered how we can view mechanical and hydraulic challenges. Pumps that are to be driven by 2-pole motors have been specifically designed for operation at 3500 rpm in order to achieve the same flow and head characteristics as those designed for operation at 1750 rpm. These new design considerations include:
• Impeller tip speeds
• Selection of appropriate bearings for the application speeds which meet the associated L10 life expectancies
• Appropriate seal face materials
• Optimal diametric running clearances between impeller skirts and the mating machined registers in the interior of the volute
• The use of modern internal volute designs that minimize velocities.

These lower internal velocities eliminate the concern that higher speeds will increase the rate of erosive wear. Today’s machines, using CFD (Computational Fluid Dynamics), are designed with flow patterns, machined tolerances, surface finishes, and many other considerations, for suitable life spans at-2 pole speeds. With CFD we can simulate sand wear as well as analyze forces and vibrations at various flows.

A special consideration that we should make when comparing 2-pole to 4-pole design and life span is impeller vane tip speeds – which will be the same regardless of how fast or slow the motor turns. This is because vane tip speed, which we measure in feet per second at the circumference of the impeller, directly influences the velocity of the pumped media. And in turn, this velocity is directly related to pumping head. In other words, in order to achieve a given head, we need a specific velocity regardless of revolutions per minute. Importantly, the majority of impeller wear occurs at the vane tips. A lower rpm motor needs a bigger diameter impeller to overcome the same head pressure as a higher rpm motor – which will use a smaller diameter impeller. With identical vane tip speed we are able to predict that there will be identical rates of erosive wear.

A smaller high-speed pump with the same impeller vane tip speed as a larger low-speed pump will therefore have a lower initial cost. Additionally, it is more expensive to replace a worn impeller on a slower pump since the part will be larger and will cost more.

Grundfos 2-poles vs 4-pole (2)

Figure 2: Flow simulations are used to predict sand wear on hydraulic components. This allows the hydraulic designer to optimize the geometry and maximize pump lifetime.

Further, since the increased speed enables the use of smaller pumps, additional benefits include a reduced footprint for use in tight mechanical rooms and lighter weight for safer handling.

Another concern is that with a larger impeller (at lower speed) – balance could become a greater issue. Imbalance will lead to bearing wear, alignment issues, poor performance, decreased efficiency, and reduced pump life.

With the support of CFD we don’t have to rely on instincts and hopes that slower speed motors will protect the pumps. We calculate and demonstrate that the pumps and materials are appropriate for the application and the design criteria.

Many thousands of successful installations over the past ten years attest to the acceptance of this 2 pole solids handling pump design by the specifying engineering community.

Related Articles

Grundfos Launches GO Solar App

Grundfos Launches GO Solar App

New global app offers a simple and convenient solution for sizing and selecting solar pump products right from your mobile…

Related Whitepapers

Carlsberg taps into process water reuse with onsite treatment

Carlsberg brewery wants to cut its water use by 50% by 2030. The initiative, Zero Water Waste, is part of Carlsberg’s Together Towards Zero program.…

Water and Wastewater Industry Checklist for Variable Speed Drives

Resilience is the ability to cope with, and recover from, disruption and to anticipate trends and variability in order to maintain services for people and…

Overcoming energy efficiency challenges in the water and wastewater industry

Water demand is continuing to increase as the global population grows. Clean water is required by people for drinking, cooking, and washing, and by industrial…

Always-on Steam Trap Monitoring Yields 2.9x Return & Reduction of CO2 Emissions [Case Study]

In 2020, Trinity Manufacturing, a premier manufacturer of specialty agriculture and water treatment chemicals, engaged Everactive to help deliver on its safety, sustainability, and operational…

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Join the #PumpTalk Community


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: raybet & raybet 雷竞技 , 2205-C 7th Street, Tuscaloosa, AL, 35401, //www.stokoptom.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email.Emails are serviced by Constant Contact